Benjamin Raphael vs Theodore Lichtenhein
1st American Chess Congress New York, NY USA round 4.2 1857.??.??
King’s Gambit Accepted 0-1

Theodore Lichtenhein vs Benjamin Raphael
1st American Chess Congress New York, NY USA round 4.3 1857.??.??
Benoni Defense: Benoni Gambit Accepted 1-0

George Nelson Cheney vs Theodore Lichtenhein
Offhand New York Chess Club 1857.??.??
King’s Gambit Accepted 1-0

Hardman Philips Montgomery vs Theodore Lichtenhein
Lichtenhein - Montgomery Match Philadelphia, PA USA (Philadelphia CC) round 8 1861.01.14
French Defense: Exchange Variation 1/2-1/2

Theodore Lichtenhein vs Hardman Philips Montgomery
Lichtenhein - Montgomery Match Philadelphia, PA USA (Philadelphia CC) round 9 1861.01.15
Ruy Lopez: Morphy Defense, Anderssen Variation 1-0

Charles Henry Stanley vs Theodore Lichtenhein
1st American Chess Congress New York, NY USA round 1.3 1857.10.12
Caro-Kann Defense: Euwe Attack, Prins Gambit 1-0

Frederick Perrin vs Theodore Lichtenhein
1st American Chess Congress New York, NY USA round 2.2 1857.10.??
Sicilian Defense: Taimanov Variation 0-1

Hardman Philips Montgomery vs Theodore Lichtenhein
Lichtenhein - Montgomery Match Philadelphia, PA USA (Philadelphia CC) round 10 1861.01.16
French Defense: Exchange Variation 0-1